Just because someone has set themselves up as an online influencer speaking about Islam, it doesn’t make them a religious authority.
The ability to speak well or attract a following doesn’t necessarily correlate with deep religious understanding or sincerity.
In fact, the influencer world often rewards traits like charisma, self-promotion, and constant visibility — traits that can sit uncomfortably alongside the Islamic emphasis on humility, sincerity, and guarding the ego.
That’s not to say all Muslim influencers are misguided or insincere — they may genuinely use their platforms to share beneficial knowledge and reminders — but it’s important not to conflate popularity with authority.
Traditional Islamic scholarship is built on rigorous study, transmission, and character refinement — not just having a social media presence.
It’s wise to be cautious and discerning about who we take as our sources of knowledge, especially in an age when anyone can publish and promote their views widely.
One thing is certain: I am not your guide. I’m just a fellow traveller trying to make sense of the world, one blog post at a time. Don’t bestow any authority on me. I’m just an opinionated fool.
Last modified: 11 April 2025
